A Lender Has Asked for Your Commission Records: What Dealers Must Do Within a Month
Motor finance lenders are asking dealers for commission and disclosure records. What the FCA rule requires, how to search, what to say if you hold nothing, and what to avoid.
If you arranged motor finance at any point since 2007, there is a good chance a lender will write to you before the motor finance compensation scheme is decided. Some dealers have already had the letter. It usually arrives as a list of agreement numbers, a request for documents, and a date.
That letter matters more than it looks. The FCA has set a timescale for answering it, the lender is under its own deadlines, and what you send back (or fail to send) may end up as evidence in a customer's complaint.
We covered the bigger picture in Car Finance Settlement Offers: What the FCA Means for Dealers. This article is the practical part: what the rule says, how to search, what to say when you hold nothing, and the mistakes that turn an admin task into a problem.
This is general information for dealers, not legal advice. If a request involves a large number of agreements, an indemnity claim or a complaint about your own conduct, take specific advice.
Why lenders are writing to dealers now
The FCA confirmed the motor finance compensation scheme on 30 March 2026. It covers agreements taken out between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024 where the lender paid commission to the broker, which in most cases means the dealer. A customer may qualify if they were not told about one of three arrangements between the lender and the broker:
- a discretionary commission arrangement, which let the broker adjust the interest rate to earn more commission;
- high commission, which the FCA defines as at least 39% of the total cost of credit and 10% of the loan;
- a contractual tie that gave the lender exclusivity or a right of first refusal.
The scheme is under legal challenge. The Upper Tribunal suspended parts of it on 2 July 2026, and the hearing is listed for 16 February to 3 March 2027. Until then, lenders do not have to calculate or pay compensation under the scheme.
What lenders do still have to do is prepare. The FCA's page for firms says that includes gathering the data needed to identify commission arrangements and disclosure practices, "including where information is held by brokers". Lenders also have to tell some complainants that they are not owed compensation. For agreements from 1 April 2014 where the complaint was made by 30 June 2026, that deadline was 18 November 2026. For earlier agreements complained about by 31 August 2026, it is 18 January 2027.
A lender cannot tell a customer they are owed nothing without evidence. Where that evidence sits in your files rather than theirs, they have to ask you.
Dealer takeaway: a records request is not an accusation. It is the lender filling gaps in its own evidence. Treat it as a deadline, not a threat.
What the FCA rule actually requires
The FCA's October 2026 guidance for firms sets out both sides of the exchange.
The lender's side. Where a lender does not hold the records it needs, it must request relevant records and information from the credit broker. If the broker does not respond within one month, or only partly responds, the lender sends a further written request giving the broker 14 more days.
Your side. Brokers are required to respond appropriately to reasonable requests from lenders within one month. The FCA says the broker must conduct a thorough search and either provide the requested information or confirm that it does not hold it.
Two things in that wording are worth reading slowly.
The first is "thorough search". A quick look in the current filing cabinet is not a thorough search if your older deal files are in a storage unit, an old DMS, or a former manager's email account.
The second is "or confirm it does not hold it". The rule does not expect you to have records you never kept or were entitled to destroy. It expects an honest, documented answer either way.
The FCA set out its expectations of brokers earlier, in a Dear CEO letter of 7 October 2025. It asked brokers to identify the lenders they used, engage with lenders collaboratively and promptly, assess the types and volumes of documents they hold, and plan for the resources that lender requests may need. It also reminded brokers of their obligation to maintain adequate financial resources.
Dealer takeaway: one month runs from the request. Diary it the day it arrives. If you cannot meet it, tell the lender before the date, not after.
What the lender is trying to prove
It helps to know what the lender is looking for, because it tells you where to search. In most cases they are trying to establish one or more of the following:
- What commission was paid on the agreement, and how it was calculated.
- Whether the rate was set by you within a band (a discretionary arrangement) or fixed by the lender.
- What the customer was told about commission and about your relationship with the lender, and when.
- Whether a tie existed that gave the lender first refusal or exclusivity.
So the documents that usually matter are the signed finance paperwork, any initial disclosure or status disclosure document, commission disclosure wording on your website or in your sales documents at the time, the deal file, and your agreements with the lender.
Log, Search, Answer, Keep: a four-step method for every request
1. Log it
Record the date the request arrived, who sent it, the lender's reference, the number of agreements and the response date. If it came by email, save the email. If it came by post, scan it.
Then check one thing straight away: is the request reasonable and clear? If you cannot tell which customers or agreements it refers to, ask the lender to clarify in writing. That is engagement, not delay.
2. Search properly
Make a list of every place records could be, then search each one and note that you did. For a typical independent, that list includes:
- the current DMS and any previous system you have moved away from;
- the finance proposal platform or lender portal you used at the time;
- paper deal files, including archived boxes;
- shared and personal email accounts, including those of staff who have left;
- your accountant or bookkeeper, for commission statements;
- your website archive, if disclosure wording sat on the site.
Older agreements are the hard part. Many dealers simply will not hold paperwork from 2008. That is not a failing in itself, but you need to be able to show where you looked.
3. Answer plainly
For each agreement, say what you hold, what you are sending, and what you do not hold. Keep it factual. If the lender asks how rates were set at the time and you know, say so. If you do not know, say that, and do not guess.
Send only what the request asks for. A request about commission does not need the customer's whole file. On data protection, sharing relevant records with the lender in response to a regulatory requirement is the kind of disclosure the rules are designed to accommodate, but sending more than is asked for creates risk without helping anyone. If you are unsure, take advice.
4. Keep the trail
Keep a copy of the request, a note of the search (where, when, by whom), what you sent and the date you sent it. The FCA expects firms to keep a clear audit trail. If the customer's complaint reaches the Financial Ombudsman Service, or the arrangement between you and the lender is later disputed, that trail is your evidence that you did what was asked.
Dealer takeaway: the method matters as much as the answer. "We searched these six places on these dates and hold nothing for this agreement" is a complete response. Silence is not.
A worked example (illustrative only)
A dealer receives a request on Tuesday 24 November asking for commission and disclosure records for 40 agreements written between 2016 and 2019. The response date is one month later, so it lands in the week of Christmas.
The dealer logs it the same day and diaries a review a fortnight in. A search of the current DMS finds nothing, because the business changed systems in 2021. The old system's export, kept on a USB drive at the time of the switch, holds deal records for 31 of the 40. Archived paper files cover four more. Five agreements have nothing anywhere.
The response goes back on 18 December: documents for 35 agreements, a short schedule showing what was sent for each, and a clear statement that no records were found for the remaining five, with the locations searched. The dealer keeps the whole bundle.
Nothing in that response is clever. It is just complete, on time and honest.
What not to do
Do not ignore it. The lender will chase, and the FCA has asked brokers to engage promptly. An unanswered request also leaves the lender unable to rebut the complaint, which helps no one.
Do not recreate documents. If a disclosure document is missing, do not draft one now and send it as if it existed at the time. That turns an evidence gap into something far more serious.
Do not speculate. "I think we probably told everyone" is not evidence. If the only answer you have is staff recollection, say that it is recollection.
Do not discuss the complaint with the customer. If a customer contacts you, point them to the lender and the FCA's information, as we set out in the settlement offers article. Do not advise them on whether they have a claim.
Do not assume the lender's terms decide who pays. Some lender and broker agreements contain indemnity or debit-back clauses. The FCA's position is that where agreements claim to reassign liability for redress, that is for the firms to resolve between themselves, but it must not delay redress to consumers. Whether a particular clause is enforceable is a separate question, which we looked at in FCA Motor Finance Redress 2026: A UK Dealer's Guide. If a lender raises one with you, get advice before you reply.
The lesson for finance you write today
Every request you answer now is a reminder of what a future request will need. For finance written today, that means a few simple habits:
- keep the signed finance documents and your disclosure wording in the same place as the deal;
- record what you told the customer about commission and your lender relationships, and when;
- keep a copy of your lender agreements and any changes to them;
- when you change systems, keep a usable export of the old one.
These habits sit alongside your Consumer Duty obligations and the same discipline that protects you in quality disputes, which we covered in Your Sales File Is Your Consumer Rights Act Defence. A DMS that keeps the customer, the vehicle, the deal and the finance paperwork together turns a request like this into a search rather than a hunt. That is the reason we built MYDEALERSHIPVIEW around the sales file rather than around the stock list.
When to get help
Most requests are straightforward. Some are not. Get support if:
- the request covers dozens or hundreds of agreements and you do not have the time to search properly within a month;
- the lender raises an indemnity, debit-back or recovery clause;
- the request suggests the lender thinks your own disclosure was the problem;
- you have found records that look unhelpful and you are unsure how to present them.
Our complaints and legal consultancy helps dealers organise records, answer lender requests and get their finance paperwork right for the future. If you want to talk it through, see how we work with dealers.
Related guides: Does a car dealer need FCA authorisation? and Trading Standards and used car dealers.
FAQs
Do car dealers have to give lenders their finance records?
If you acted as the credit broker, yes, where the request is reasonable. The FCA says brokers must respond to reasonable lender requests within one month, either by providing the information or by confirming they do not hold it after a thorough search.
How long do dealers have to respond to a lender's records request?
One month from the request. If you do not respond, or only partly respond, the lender sends a further written request giving you 14 more days.
What if we no longer have the records?
Say so clearly, agreement by agreement, and record where you searched. The rule allows for confirming you do not hold information. Do not recreate missing documents.
Will dealers have to pay motor finance compensation?
The scheme places redress on lenders. The FCA has not made brokers liable under it. Separate commercial agreements between lenders and dealers may try to pass costs on, and the FCA says that is for the firms to resolve between themselves. Whether a particular clause works depends on its wording, so take advice if one is raised.
Has the motor finance compensation scheme been paused?
Parts of it have been suspended pending a legal challenge, with the hearing listed for 16 February to 3 March 2027. Lenders must still prepare, which is why records requests are arriving now.
Sources
- FCA, FCA confirms motor finance redress scheme (30 March 2026, updated 14 September 2026)
- FCA, Motor finance scheme partially suspended (2 July 2026)
- FCA, Motor finance legal challenge to be heard in February 2027 (13 October 2026, updated 26 October 2026)
- FCA, Further information for firms on the motor finance compensation scheme (October 2026), sections 3.6 and 4
- FCA, Information for firms on motor finance complaints (updated 3 November 2026)
- FCA, Dear CEO letter: motor finance, action for lenders and brokers (7 October 2025)