Car Finance Settlement Offers: What the FCA Means for Dealers
Lenders can now make settlement offers while the redress scheme is challenged. What the FCA said on 3 November, what it means for dealers, and how to answer customers.
Car Finance Settlement Offers: What the FCA's November Statement Means for Dealers
The short answer: on 3 November 2026 the FCA said motor finance lenders can make settlement offers to customers now, rather than waiting for the redress scheme, as long as the offer is no less than the customer would get under the scheme. The statement is about lenders. It says nothing about dealers or brokers, and it creates no new dealer liability. What it does change is the conversations customers will start having with you, and the importance of having your finance records ready when a lender asks.
For the background on how the scheme works, what a discretionary commission arrangement is, and the indemnity clauses in dealer agreements, see our guide to the FCA motor finance redress scheme. This article covers what has happened since.
What did the FCA say on 3 November?
The FCA said it supports lenders making settlement offers outside the scheme, on conditions:
The offer must be no less than the customer would receive through the scheme.
The lender must be clear what accepting means. The customer keeps the money even if the legal challenge would have meant they'd get less, and can't claim more later if it would have meant more. An accepted offer can't be reopened.
Offers can't be referred to the Financial Ombudsman for review.
Lenders must give customers an FCA factsheet, must tell the FCA about their plans, and the FCA will publish which lenders are making offers.
The FCA also confirmed that firms don't need to calculate or pay compensation under the scheme until the legal process concludes. At least one lender has said it will make offers to some customers.
The FCA's message to consumers is that there's no obligation to accept. Its factsheet says the FCA hasn't assessed individual offers and that customers don't need a claims management company or law firm to accept or reject one.
Where does the redress scheme stand now?
The scheme was confirmed in March 2026 and covers agreements taken out between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024 where there was a discretionary commission arrangement, a high commission arrangement, or an undisclosed tied arrangement. The FCA estimates around 12.1 million eligible agreements and about £7.5 billion in redress, an average of around £830 per agreement.
It was legally challenged, and in July 2026 the Upper Tribunal suspended parts of it. Lenders don't have to calculate or pay redress on the scheme's timetable, but they must still follow the rules that aren't suspended, including identifying complaints and agreements and responding to complainants who aren't owed anything. The challenge is due to be heard by the Upper Tribunal between 16 February and 3 March 2027. The FCA has told firms to keep preparing, and also to prepare for the possibility that the scheme is quashed in whole or in part.
Does this change anything for dealers?
Not in law. The FCA's statement on settlement offers doesn't mention dealers or brokers at all. Responsibility for redress under the scheme sits with the lender, and the FCA describes any debit-back of commission between lender and broker as a commercial arrangement between them. That's why your agreements with lenders matter; our redress guide explains why a lender's terms don't automatically override your own.
In practice, three things change:
More customers will ask you about it. Some will have had an offer letter, some a "not owed" letter, and some will have seen headlines.
Lenders will be pulling records. Making offers means lenders need agreement and commission data now, not after the hearing.
Timing is less predictable. Some customers will be settled in the coming months while others wait into 2027 or beyond.
What should you say when a customer asks about a claim?
Stick to facts, point to the right place and keep a note. A sensible approach is:
Tell them who to contact. Complaints and offers are handled by the lender. If they don't know who the lender was, help them find out from your records; the FCA's own consumer page tells customers to ask the dealer if they're unsure.
Point them to the FCA's information rather than giving your own view. The FCA has a consumer page on car finance complaints and a factsheet on settlement offers.
Don't advise on whether to accept an offer. You're not in a position to know whether it's right for them, and it isn't your decision.
Be accurate about claims firms. The FCA says customers don't need a claims management company or law firm to take part, and that fees can be up to 36% including VAT. You can repeat that; don't go further.
Stay courteous and don't be defensive. A customer asking about a claim is exercising a right, not accusing you of anything.
Record the conversation and what you told them.
The Consumer Duty applies to how you communicate with finance customers going forward, and the FCA expects brokers and dealers to present information in a way that helps customers make informed decisions. Our guide to the Consumer Duty for dealers explains the standard. A calm, factual answer at the counter is consistent with it.
What records should you have ready?
The FCA requires brokers to respond appropriately to reasonable requests from lenders within one month. That means carrying out a thorough search and either providing the information or confirming you don't hold it. If you respond only in part, or not at all, the lender can chase and allow a further 14 days.
Have these findable, by customer and agreement, going back as far as you hold them:
- Commission arrangements with each lender, including any rate-setting discretion.
- What you disclosed to customers about commission and lender relationships, and when.
- Sales files for finance deals: proposals, signed documents, and notes of what was explained.
- Lender panel and introducer agreements, including indemnity and debit-back clauses.
- Records of any finance complaints you received and how they were handled.
If some records are gone, say so clearly when asked; the FCA's process allows a broker to confirm it doesn't hold information. What creates problems is silence or a scramble. A searchable sales file makes this a short job rather than a week in the archive. If you also sell cars on sale or return, check those agreements are documented properly too; see our guide to SOR agreements and the FCA.
Key dates to watch
18 November 2026: lenders' deadline to respond to complainants who aren't owed anything, for agreements from 1 April 2014 where the complaint was made by 30 June 2026. Expect some customers to come to you with those letters.
18 January 2027: the equivalent deadline for agreements before 1 April 2014 where the complaint was made by 31 August 2026.
16 February to 3 March 2027: the Upper Tribunal hearing on the legal challenges.
31 August 2027: the date the FCA gives for customers who haven't complained to bring a claim under the scheme.
Dates can move. Check the FCA's motor finance pages before relying on them.
Get help with records and lender requests
Our complaints and legal consultancy helps dealers organise finance records, respond to lender requests, review lender agreements and handle customer complaints. We also work with a network of independent dealers who share what they've learned with the dealers we partner with. Talk to us about partnering with MYDEALERSHIPVIEW.
This article is general information, not legal or regulatory advice. Check the FCA's current publications, and take advice on your own agreements and records.
Related guides: Does a car dealer need FCA authorisation? and Lender asked for your commission records?.