How to Run a Used Car Dealership: The 6 Numbers to Check Every Week
Running a used car dealership well comes down to a handful of numbers checked every week. The six that matter, what good looks like, and what to do when one slips.
In short: a used car dealership runs on six numbers. Check them every week: average days in stock, profit per car after prep, cars over 60 days, how fast you answer leads, how many enquiries turn into sales, and open complaints. If all six are healthy, the business usually is. If one slips, it tells you exactly where to look.
1. Average days in stock
How long your cars take to sell. Autotrader reported an average of 31 days across the market in 2025 and 27 days in October 2026, so if your average is well above that, your pricing, sourcing or presentation needs attention. See how to reduce days in stock.
2. Profit per car after prep
Not the gap between buy and sell price, but what is left after prep, fees, warranty, finance costs and any VAT. Many dealers find their real figure is well below the number they quote. See true profit on a used car and the VAT margin scheme.
3. Cars over 60 days
Aged stock ties up cash, costs interest if it is funded, and usually needs a price cut. List every car past 60 days each week and decide: reprice, re-photograph, re-advertise or trade out. See pricing discipline for used stock and Autotrader price indicators.
4. Lead response time
How long an enquiry waits before someone replies, and how many calls go unanswered. Buyers contact several dealers, and the first useful reply often wins. See missed calls and lead response.
5. Enquiry to sale conversion
Of the leads you received, how many bought? Track it by source (Autotrader, your website, Facebook, walk-ins) so you know which channels pay. A low rate usually points to slow responses, weak follow-up or stock that doesn't match what you advertise. See getting the most from Autotrader and owning your customer base.
6. Open complaints
How many complaints are open, how old they are and whether each has a next step and a date. A complaint left to drift is the one that becomes a rejection, a lender query or a public review. See handling used car complaints and the real cost of a customer complaint.
A simple weekly routine
| When | What to do |
| Monday | Review the six numbers against last week |
| Monday | Decide on every car over 60 days |
| Midweek | Check unanswered leads and follow-ups |
| Friday | Check each open complaint has a next step and a date |
| Month end | Profit per car by source and by month |
Where to get the numbers from
If the six numbers take an afternoon to build from spreadsheets, they won't get checked every week. A dealer management system should show them without any manual work: stock age, profit after costs, leads by source and open complaints, all in one place. See what is a dealer management system and DMS vs spreadsheet.
If you are planning to grow, these numbers are your early warning. See growing from 20 to 50 cars.
What it looks like in practice
MWA Autos moved from a VBA spreadsheet to a full DMS with real-time data and lead automation. Bluebell Motorhouse replaced manual admin with one system. More in our case studies.
Score your dealership
How does your dealership stack up? The free Dealer Growth Scorecard takes six quick questions and gives you an instant breakdown of profit tracking, lead handling, admin and marketing.