AutoTrader Price Indicator and Price Position Explained for Dealers
A plain guide to AutoTrader's price labels, Price Position and Retail Rating, and how to use them to price each car on purpose rather than by habit.
In short: AutoTrader's price indicator compares your advertised price with AutoTrader's own valuation of that car. Slightly under the valuation earns a Great price label, very close earns Good, and slightly over earns Fair. Price Position shows the same comparison as a percentage, where 100% is the valuation, and it includes your admin fee. Read it alongside Retail Rating, which shows how quickly the car should sell, so you only give away margin on the cars that need it.
What the AutoTrader price indicator shows
The coloured label on your advert tells buyers how your price compares with the market. AutoTrader's help centre sets out five levels:
| Label | What AutoTrader says it means |
| Lower price | Priced much lower than the valuation |
| Great price | Slightly cheaper than the valuation |
| Good price | Priced very closely to the valuation |
| Fair price | Only slightly more expensive than the valuation |
| Higher price | More expensive than the valuation, though there may be reasons for this |
AutoTrader doesn't publish the exact percentage bands behind each label, so be wary of figures passed around the trade. Your own Price Position, covered below, is the number to watch.
You may also see two other states. No analysis means there isn't enough market data to rate the car. Updating appears after a price change: the label is removed while it recalculates, which AutoTrader says takes around 15 minutes, so buyers never see an out of date rating.
How AutoTrader values the car behind the label
Every label is measured against the AutoTrader Retail Valuation, a live view of what a retailer could expect to sell the car for. It is calculated from the advertised retail prices of similar vehicles over the last 28 days, so it moves with the market rather than staying fixed from the day you listed.
Two details matter for dealers:
- Spec counts. Specification and optional extras are taken into account, and the valuation is adjusted for the optional spec you add to the advert. If you leave out a panoramic roof or a premium pack, your car is compared with a lower spec car and your price looks higher than it really is.
- History and ownership don't. AutoTrader states that service history, the number of owners and the retailer selling the car do not affect its valuations. A full history, one owner car will not earn a better label, so sell those strengths in your photos and description instead.
Price Position: the number that matters more than the label
Price Position shows your planned retail price as a percentage of the Retail Valuation. At 100% you are priced exactly at the valuation; below 100% you are under the market and above 100% you are over it.
AutoTrader includes admin fees in the price it uses for Price Position. Any admin fee therefore pushes the car further up the scale, and under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act it has to be in the headline price anyway. We cover that in what the DMCCA requires in your price.
Retail Rating: how fast the car should sell
Retail Rating is a score out of 100 showing how popular a vehicle is in the current market. The higher the score, the quicker AutoTrader expects you to sell it.
This is the context the price label lacks. AutoTrader itself has said that not every vehicle should be priced at 100% Price Position, and that you need to factor in how desirable the car is in your area, measured by Retail Rating.
How to use the three together
As a starting point, set each car's price according to its Retail Rating rather than chasing the same label on every car:
| Retail Rating | Starting approach |
| High | Buyers want this car. Start at or slightly above 100% and accept a Fair label. Cutting to Great on a car that would sell anyway gives margin away. |
| Middle | Price close to 100% for a Good label and review it weekly as the valuation moves. |
| Low | Expect a slower sale. Price below 100% from the start, or reconsider buying the car at that price. |
These are starting points, not rules. Your local market, your stock mix and how long you can afford to hold a car all change the answer. What matters is that every price is a decision, not a habit. For more on that, see pricing discipline for used stock and how to reduce days in stock.
Price it before you buy it: working retail back
The best time to think about the price indicator is before you buy the car. AutoTrader calls this working retail back: start with the Retail Valuation, take off your expected preparation costs and your target margin, and what is left is the most you should pay.
Example figures only: a Retail Valuation of £12,000, less £600 of preparation and a £1,500 target margin, gives a maximum buy price of £9,900. Pay more than that and you either sell at a Fair or Higher price, or accept a smaller margin.
Remember that margin here is before VAT. If you sell under the margin scheme, VAT comes out of that margin, as explained in our VAT margin scheme guide. Our guides to part-exchange valuation and calculating the true profit on a used car go further.
Common mistakes
- Chasing Great price on every car. It sells popular cars no faster than Good or Fair would, and costs margin on each one.
- Missing spec. Unlisted options lower the valuation you are compared against and make your price look high.
- Forgetting the admin fee. It is part of Price Position and must be in the advertised price.
- Setting the price once. The valuation is built from the last 28 days of the market, so a price that was right on day one can drift.
- Cutting the price when the advert is the problem. AutoTrader's Advert Performance Rating compares your response with what it expects, from Low to Excellent. A car that is well priced but getting few enquiries may need better photos or a better description, not a lower price. Our guide to vehicle photography mistakes is a good place to start.
Where your DMS fits in
The price indicator tells you where your price sits against the market. It can't tell you what you will make. That depends on what you paid, what you spent on preparation and how VAT applies, which is why those figures belong on the vehicle record in your dealer management system. With them in one place, every price change shows the margin left before you make it.
For more on running AutoTrader alongside your DMS, read getting the most from AutoTrader, or see how MYDEALERSHIPVIEW handles margins and VAT.
Related guides: AutoTrader vs Cazoo vs CarGurus, Do you pay VAT on used cars? and Should you buy stock in December?.