# Wear and Tear or a Fault? How Dealers Should Answer a Consumer Rights Act Complaint > Is wear and tear covered by the Consumer Rights Act? How durability, the six-month rule and evidence decide whether a used car fault is the dealer's problem. - Type: Blog article - Publisher: MYDEALERSHIPVIEW (https://mydealershipview.com) - Author: MYDEALERSHIPVIEW - Published: 2026-11-20 - Last updated: 2026-11-22 - Canonical page: https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/wear-and-tear-or-fault-consumer-rights-act "It's wear and tear" is probably the most common sentence in used car complaint handling. It is also one of the least understood. Sometimes it is exactly right. Sometimes it is a dealer reaching for a phrase instead of reaching for evidence. This week gave a good example of why the difference matters. On 18 November, North Ayrshire Licensing Board heard an objection to the renewal of a second-hand dealer's licence held by Irvine Car Centre. According to [Car Dealer Magazine's report](https://cardealermagazine.co.uk/scottish-car-dealer-keeps-licence-despite-customer-complaint-over-faulty-car/329011), the customer had bought an 11-year-old Nissan Qashqai earlier in the year. Before handover it failed an MOT on suspension arms, bulbs and wiper blades, was repaired and passed a retest. After a slow puncture and a battery replaced under warranty, the customer reported a broken coil spring about three months after purchase. The dealer said the car had covered around 1,600 miles since the sale, that the spring was wear and tear, and that the repair would cost about £30. The customer said an independent inspection had found other problems that, in the inspector's opinion, existed before the sale. The board renewed the licence, said the vehicle dispute was a civil matter, and warned the dealer that further similar complaints could bring him back before it. We are not going to decide that dispute. We do not have the evidence, and neither did the board. What the case shows is that the argument over a £30 spring ended up in front of a licensing committee, and that neither side's position was settled by the phrase "wear and tear". It would have been settled, if at all, by evidence. _This is general information for dealers, not legal advice. Every complaint turns on its own facts._ ### "Wear and tear" is not in the Consumer Rights Act The Consumer Rights Act 2015 does not use the phrase. When a dealer says "wear and tear", what they are really making is an argument about two things the Act does contain: **satisfactory quality**, and in particular **durability**, and the **six-month presumption**. #### Satisfactory quality and durability Under section 9, goods must be of satisfactory quality. That means the standard a reasonable person would consider satisfactory, taking account of any description of the goods, the price, and all other relevant circumstances. For a used car, age, mileage, history and price are obviously relevant circumstances. Section 9(3) lists aspects of quality, including fitness for the usual purposes, freedom from minor defects, safety and **durability**. Durability is the heart of the wear-and-tear argument. A reasonable person does not expect an 11-year-old car with 100,000 miles to have the life left in its components that a two-year-old car has. They do expect it to be usable and safe for a reasonable period for its age and price. Section 9(4) adds that the quality requirement does not cover anything specifically drawn to the consumer's attention before the contract, or anything an examination they actually carried out ought to have revealed. That is why disclosure matters so much. #### The six-month presumption If a fault appears within six months of delivery, section 19 presumes the goods did not conform when delivered. The trader can rebut that by showing otherwise. The presumption also does not apply where it is incompatible with the nature of the goods or of the fault. That last point is where a genuine wear-and-tear case sits in the first six months. If a component has failed because it reached the end of a normal life that started long before the sale, the presumption may not fit. But the dealer still has to show it, and "the car is old" is not proof. After six months, the position reverses in practice. The customer has to show the fault was there at delivery. We cover the time-based rules (30 days, six months, repair first) in detail in our [Consumer Rights Act guide for used car dealers](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/used-car-dealers-consumer-rights-act). > **Dealer takeaway:** "wear and tear" is shorthand for "this car met the durability a reasonable buyer would expect for its age, mileage and price, and this failure is consistent with that". You need evidence for each part of that sentence. ### What the courts have actually said Two Scottish cases are useful because they show how this works in practice. Courts in England and Wales are not bound by them, but they apply the same statutory test. **Thain v Anniesland Trade Centre [1997] SLT (Sh Ct) 102.** A buyer paid £2,995 for a five to six-year-old Renault 19 with about 80,000 miles. Around two weeks later the automatic gearbox developed a bearing noise and eventually needed replacing. The buyer sought to reject the car. The court held it was of satisfactory quality: a reasonable person would accept that a gearbox failure could happen at any time on a car of that age, mileage and price, and would not expect durability of that kind from it. The case was decided under the Sale of Goods Act, but the satisfactory quality test it applied was carried into the Consumer Rights Act. See [what replaced the Sale of Goods Act](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/sale-of-goods-act-used-cars). **Hopkinson v Black Horse Ltd [2025] SAC (Civ) 43.** A second-hand BMW, first registered in 2018 and bought on hire purchase in February 2022, suffered failed clutch packs inside a sealed transmission around nine months later, after passing an MOT in September 2022. The buyer argued the clutch packs were lifetime components. The Sheriff Appeal Court upheld the decision that he had not validly rejected the car. As reported, the Sheriff Principal said "the absence of any evidence on the question of durability was fatal" to the buyer's position, and that no evidence had been led to show a latent defect at delivery. The same report notes a different 2025 sheriff court decision where a latent timing belt defect was found on expert evidence. Read together, the cases make the same point from both directions. Age, mileage and price really do lower what a reasonable buyer can expect. But the outcome followed the evidence each time, not the label. ### The four questions that decide a wear-and-tear complaint When a customer reports that a part has failed, work through these before you reply. We call them **Component, Clock, Expectation, Disclosure**. #### 1. Component: what exactly failed, and why? Name the part and the failure. "Suspension problem" is not enough. "Front offside coil spring fractured at the lower coil" is. Then ask what caused it. A spring that was already cracked or badly corroded at the point of sale is a different case from one that snapped months later after a pothole. A diagnosis from someone competent, with photographs, is worth more than any argument. #### 2. Clock: when did it fail, relative to the sale? Note the delivery date, the date the fault was reported, and the miles covered since sale. Inside six months, you carry the burden of showing the fault was not there at delivery. Outside six months, the customer carries it. Miles matter as well as months: 1,600 miles in three months tells a different story from 9,000. #### 3. Expectation: what would a reasonable buyer expect of this car? This is where age, mileage, price and history come in. Is the component one that normally wears and is replaced in service (pads, discs, tyres, wiper blades, clutches on many cars)? Or one that usually lasts much longer? The honest answer depends on the car. Where you are relying on a typical life for a component, get that from a technician or manufacturer information, not from memory. #### 4. Disclosure: what did you tell them, and what did they see? Did your PDI record the condition of that component? Did the MOT history show an advisory on it? Did you point it out, in writing, before the sale? Section 9(4) means a defect specifically drawn to the buyer's attention before the contract does not make the car unsatisfactory. This is the single biggest reason to record condition properly, which we cover in our guide to [the PDI checklist as a Consumer Rights Act defence](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/pdi-checklist-consumer-rights-act-defence) and [Fix It or Disclose It](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/fix-it-or-disclose-it). > **Dealer takeaway:** if you can answer all four questions with documents, you have a position. If you can only answer them with opinion, you have a hope. ### What a pass on the MOT does and does not prove Dealers often point to a recent MOT pass as proof that a car was fine. It helps, but less than people think. An MOT is a check of specified items on the day of the test, to a minimum standard. It does not assess durability, and it does not look inside a gearbox or an engine. It can cut both ways, too. An advisory for a corroded spring or a worn bush is useful evidence that the condition was known, and useful evidence against a dealer who did not mention it. See [Common MOT Advisories That Quietly Kill a Sale](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/mot-advisories-that-kill-a-sale). ### When it turns out to be a fault Sometimes the four questions point the other way. If the evidence suggests the car was not of satisfactory quality when it was delivered, the customer's remedies follow the Act. Outside the first 30 days, that normally means a repair or replacement first. Only if that fails does the customer get the final right to reject or a price reduction. One point that surprises some dealers: for most goods, there is no deduction for use if the final right to reject is used in the first six months. Motor vehicles are an exception. Section 24(10) allows a deduction for use on a car even within that period. A warranty doesn't change any of this. See [do used car dealers have to give a warranty?](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/do-used-car-dealers-have-to-give-a-warranty) ### The commercial question nobody asks early enough In the Irvine case, the repair was said to cost about £30. The dispute went on to involve [Trading Standards](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/trading-standards-used-car-dealers) advice, an independent inspection and a licensing hearing. Even where a dealer is legally right, the cost of being right can be far higher than the cost of the part. That does not mean paying for every worn component. It means deciding deliberately. Sometimes the right answer is a clear, evidenced explanation of why the part is wear and tear. Sometimes it is a goodwill repair, made clearly without admitting liability, because the relationship and the time are worth more. The mistake is drifting into a long argument without ever making that decision. Our complaints guide covers how to assess before you argue: [How to Handle Used Car Complaints Under the Consumer Rights Act](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/handling-used-car-complaints). ### How to make the next one easier - Record the condition of wear items at PDI, with photographs and tread or pad measurements. - Keep the MOT history and any advisories in the sales file, and show the customer. - Put specific disclosures in writing and get them acknowledged before the sale. - When a complaint arrives, get a proper diagnosis before you reply. - Keep every message, every date and every mile in one place. That last point is where most dealers struggle, because the evidence is spread across a phone, an inbox, a paper file and a workshop sheet. Our [complaints and aftersales management](https://mydealershipview.com/solutions/complaints-and-aftersales-management) tools keep it together, and the [sales file](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/sales-file-consumer-rights-act-defence) does the rest. If a complaint is already heading somewhere uncomfortable, our [complaints and legal consultancy](https://mydealershipview.com/services-complaints-legal) can review the file before you reply. Our knowledge is free. Our experience is earned. **Part of our Consumer Rights Act series.** For the full picture of your obligations when selling used cars, start with [the complete Consumer Rights Act guide for used car dealers](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/used-car-dealers-consumer-rights-act). **Related guides:** [Do used car dealers have to give a warranty?](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/do-used-car-dealers-have-to-give-a-warranty), [The Sale of Goods Act and used cars](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/sale-of-goods-act-used-cars), [Trading Standards and used car dealers](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/trading-standards-used-car-dealers) and [the real cost of a customer complaint](https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/cost-of-a-customer-complaint-car-dealer). **See it in practice:** how [Ideal Car Ltd](https://mydealershipview.com/case-studies/ideal-car-ltd) went from escalating complaints and spreadsheet risk to a formal complaints process, reviewed terms and migrated accounts. More client stories are in our [case studies](https://mydealershipview.com/case-studies). ### FAQs Is wear and tear covered by the Consumer Rights Act? The Act does not mention wear and tear. It requires goods to be of satisfactory quality, including durability, judged against what a reasonable person would expect given the car's description, price, age, mileage and other circumstances. A part that fails through normal wear consistent with those factors may not make the car unsatisfactory. The dealer still needs evidence. Who has to prove a fault was there when the car was sold? If the fault appears within six months of delivery, it is presumed to have been present at delivery unless the dealer shows otherwise, or the presumption is incompatible with the nature of the goods or the fault. After six months, the customer has to prove it. Does an old, high-mileage car mean the dealer isn't liable? No. Age, mileage and price lower what a reasonable buyer can expect, but they do not remove the duty. Courts have gone both ways on second-hand cars, depending on the evidence about the component and when the defect arose. Can a customer reject a used car because a part wore out? Not simply because a part wore out. If the evidence shows the car was not of satisfactory quality at delivery, the customer has remedies under the Act, which outside the first 30 days normally start with repair. Does a recent MOT pass prove the car was of satisfactory quality? It is helpful evidence of the car's condition on the test day, but it is limited. An MOT does not test durability or inspect many major components internally. ### Sources - Car Dealer Magazine, [Scottish car dealer keeps licence despite customer complaint over faulty car](https://cardealermagazine.co.uk/scottish-car-dealer-keeps-licence-despite-customer-complaint-over-faulty-car/329011) (20 November 2026) - Consumer Rights Act 2015, [section 9 (Part 1, Chapter 2)](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/15/part/1/chapter/2/2015-10-01), [section 19 explanatory notes](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/15/section/19/notes), [section 24](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/15/section/24) - Case summary, [Thain v Anniesland Trade Centre [1997]](https://casejudgments.com/?p=542) - Scottish Legal News, [Purchaser of second-hand car that suffered clutch failure two months after MOT loses appeal](https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/purchaser-of-second-hand-car-that-suffered-clutch-failure-two-months-after-mot-loses-appeal-against-sheriffs-decision) (12 December 2025) --- Source: https://mydealershipview.com/blogs/wear-and-tear-or-fault-consumer-rights-act Index of all pages: https://mydealershipview.com/llms.txt